Pesticide and Environmental Update
Organically Grown Pecans Show Significantly
Higher Yields vs Conventionally Grown!
By Alfredo Flores
Pecan growers might be able to boost their profits by growing pecans organically, according to Agricultural Research Service (ARS) scientists studying production systems for this popular tree nut.
U.S. growers provide about 90 percent of the world's pecans, with an annual crop of about 200 million pounds worth about $400 million. Pecans, popular in baked goods and confections, are a good source of protein and contain antioxidants and plant sterols thought to be beneficial to human health.
In 2002, ARS scientists led by Joe Bradford, research leader at the agency's Integrated Farming and Natural Resources Research Unit in Weslaco, Texas, began transitioning a 27-year-old, conventionally managed pecan orchard to a certified-organic-managed system. The 20-acre test site is located within the Gebert commercial pecan orchard in Comanche County in north-central Texas.
The primary objective of the project is to provide information to pecan growers on how to convert from conventional management systems that rely on synthetic chemicals to an organic system.
Contrary to conventional growers' expectations, the ARS organically treated test site out-yielded the conventionally managed, chemically fertilized Gebert orchard in each of the past five years. Yields on ARS' organic test site surpassed the Gebert commercial orchard by 18 pounds per tree in 2005, and by 12 pounds per tree in 2007.
The conventional management system generates about $1,750 per acre when the crop is sold. But the ARS certified-organic-management system would gross $5,290 per acre.
These greater dollar returns prove that adopting an organic system and obtaining certification could provide more income for pecan growers, thanks to increased yields and improved kernel quality.
Organic Pecans: Another Option for Growers
ARS scientists in Weslaco, Texas, are developing new methods to increase yields and organically manage pecan trees.
The pecan’s name comes from an Algonquian word meaning “a nut that requires a stone to crack.” Widely consumed out of hand and used as an ingredient in baked goods and confections, pecans are a good source of protein. And the antioxidants and plant sterols they contain may improve consumers’ cholesterol status by reducing the “bad” LDL cholesterol levels.
Despite only having commercially produced the nut since the 1880s, U.S. growers now provide roughly 90 percent of the world’s pecans, with an annual crop of about 200 million pounds worth about $400 million dollars.
New ARS studies in Weslaco, Texas, are showing that it may be possible for growers to boost their revenue further by growing pecans organically.
In 2002, ARS scientists—led by Joe Bradford, research leader for the Integrated Farming and Natural Resources Research Unit in Weslaco—began transitioning part of a 27-year-old pecan orchard from conventional management to certified-organic management. The 20-acre test site is located within the Adolph (Sonny) and Noreen Gebert pecan orchard in Comanche County, in north-central Texas.
Bradford was contacted by Sonny Gebert in 2001, after Gebert tuned in to a radio show during which the two hosts mentioned Bradford’s research on organic crops. Gebert then phoned Bradford, and the two arranged to meet in Goldthwaite, Texas, at a Texas A&M workshop in 2002. Gebert agreed to let Bradford and his collaborators manage half of the nearly 800 pecan trees in the Gebert orchard using organic principles. ARS would manage the older portion of the orchard, which was planted in 1981. The Geberts would continue to manage the newer portion, planted in 1986.
The main objective of the project is to provide pecan growers with information on how to convert to an organic system from a conventional management system that relies on synthetic chemicals. Bradford and his technicians are constantly changing the variables within the system and examining the interactions that result from those changes.
Healthier Trees From Healthy Soil
The ARS organic management system was based on first increasing soil organic matter, balancing the nutrients and biology of the soil, and using organic pesticides only when needed. Bradford theorized that by improving tree health through improved soil health, the trees would naturally become more resistant to disease and insect attack. The researchers decided to evaluate several soil treatments in the test orchard and to treat the trees aboveground using organic methods. They began applying treatments in the fall of 2002, shortly after their first summer visit with Sonny Gebert.
They studied five pecan varieties—Caddo, Cheyenne, Desirable, Pawnee, and Wichita—applying various organic amendments several times during the year, both to the soil and to the leaves. As many as 15 soil fertility and biological treatments were applied, while the aboveground portion of the orchard received a uniform foliar treatment. Treatments used include poultry litter and compost, rock minerals, mycorrhizal fungi, and nutrients such as iron, zinc, boron, copper, and manganese.
Since the death of Sonny Gebert in early 2008, management of his pecan orchard has been taken over by Danny Phillips, a retired Extension agent from Hamilton County who is employed by Noreen Gebert. The ARS scientists continue to travel to the orchard about once each month from March until the November harvest—the growing season for pecans—to apply soil treatments and compost teas.
Larry Zibilske, a soil scientist in Bradford’s research unit, became involved in the project during the 2008 growing season. He is measuring changes in soil microbial properties resulting from the various treatments applied over the last 6 years. As soil fertility increases with organic treatments, microbial populations benefit greatly. Not only do they become more diverse, they also take a more active role in providing nutrients to the trees and protecting the roots from pathogens. The key is to modify the soil microbial habitat so that the beneficial organisms persist and provide a lasting, nurturing environment for the trees.
Evaluating the Results
Contrary to conventional growers’ expectations, the ARS organically treated test site outyielded the Geberts’ conventionally managed, chemically fertilized orchard in each of 5 years. The best ARS treatment surpassed the Gebert control by 18 pounds per tree—44.10 pounds compared to 25.85 pounds—in 2005 and by 12 pounds per tree—45.09 pounds compared to 33.39 pounds—in 2007. Because pecans are an alternate-bearing tree, both orchards’ yields were very low in 2004 and 2006.
Compost tea is sprayed on the organic trees once every 6 weeks throughout the growing season. Compost tea improves plant health and helps to control insects and diseases.
“This is the most successful organic project I have been involved with,” says Bradford. “The results are especially satisfying, because we have shown that it’s possible to grow nuts under the organic system that are far superior in looks and in taste.”
Also involved in the project are plant physiologist Nasir Malik and entomologist Allan Showler, who both work in Bradford’s unit. Malik and Showler will next compare some of the nutritional values of the organic and conventional pecans harvested this fall.
But What About Pecan Pests?
Another positive result was that the ARS researchers learned how—with the help of beneficial Trichogramma wasps—to control the pecan casebearer. As one of pecans’ major pests, the larvae of this one-third-inch-long gray moth tunnel into the small, immature nutlets, killing them. The very tiny parasitic wasps of the genus Trichogramma lay their eggs inside casebearer eggs, turning them black and preventing the casebearer larvae within from developing.
As a backup control, the scientists used the organic bacterial insecticide known as “spinosad,” which is derived naturally from a soil-dwelling bacterium, Saccharopolyspora spinosa.
The researchers also found that foliar applications of compost tea—a brew made of compost, small amounts of food sources for microbes, and water—somewhat increased trees’ resistance to insects and achieved some disease control when applied each month after flowering. They think that another major pest of pecans, the pecan weevil, was somewhat controlled by compost tea applied to soil. Additional research in 2008 will verify whether this treatment will be added to the recommendations by Bradford and his team.
Currently, ARS scientists are working to better control pecan scab caused by a fungus that, if not curbed, can cause entire crops from most varieties to be lost during periods of frequent rains or extended dew. Scab is the most destructive disease of pecans in the hot, humid South.
The researchers also believe that the alternate-bearing characteristic of pecan production will lessen—or disappear—after several years of organic management. ARS data shows that pecan trees in the Hamilton organic orchard bear 40 pounds per tree in the good years and about 4 pounds per tree in the lower yielding years—a drastic difference that can make or break some of the smaller pecan producers. Bradford thinks that the organic system will eventually even out the wild discrepancies between the good and bad yields.
“This year, which is the low-yield year in the alternate-bearing cycle, the conventional orchard has few to no pecans, yet our organic orchard has a lot of pecans. The typical 4 pounds per tree measured in 2004 and 2006 could be at least 15-20 pounds this year,” he says.
Pecans from the Gebert orchard generally sell for about $2.00 per pound wholesale. Using the average yield for the conventional management system of 25 pounds per tree and roughly 35 trees per acre, sale of the crop generates about $1,750 per acre (25x35x$2). But the ARS best-management organic system yield of 44 pounds per tree would gross $3,080 per acre (44x35x$2), for an increase in sales of $1,330 per acre. While production costs add about $100 per acre, the value of the pecans is increased by at least $1.50 per pound. Thus, pecans harvested from an orchard certified as organic would generate $5,290 per acre [(44x35x$3.50) – $100]—for an increase of $3,540 per acre above the returns from the conventional management system.
These greater dollar returns prove that adopting an organic system and obtaining certification could provide a valuable additional source of income to pecan growers, thanks to increased yields and improved kernel quality.
“I believe our greatest accomplishment is that we, as scientists, have shown it’s possible to design a management system that growers will adopt,” says Bradford. “That’s really the biggest thing—to prove that this is a change for the better.”
He also notes that converting pecan production from conventional to organic can translate to other crops. “We think that the techniques we’ve tested here can apply to peaches, apricots, apples, walnuts—to all tree crops, and to plants in general.”—By Alfredo Flores, Agricultural Research Service Information Staff.